Licensed & Insured · Locally Owned · Free Inspections Call (210) 504-1295
W Wannamaker Roofing San Antonio's Trusted Roofer
· 7 min read

Chimney Flashing Failures & How to Spot T… | Wannamaker

If you've got a leak and can't figure out where it's coming from, look at your chimney. The junction where a chimney meets the roof deck is one of the most leak-prone areas on any residential roof — and in San Antonio, our heat cycles, hail events, and occasional downpours put chimney flashing under more stress than most homeowners realize. The good news: flashing failures almost always give warning signs before they cause serious interior damage. You just have to know what to look for.

What Chimney Flashing Actually Does

Chimney flashing is a system of metal pieces — usually aluminum, galvanized steel, or copper — that seals the gap between your chimney and your roof. Without it, rainwater would pour straight down the sides of the chimney and into your attic, walls, and ceilings.

A properly installed chimney flashing system has multiple components:

  • Step flashing. L-shaped metal pieces woven into the shingle courses along each side of the chimney.
  • Base (apron) flashing. A continuous piece at the bottom of the chimney face that diverts water around the sides.
  • Counter flashing. Metal embedded or cut into the chimney mortar joints that overlaps the step and base flashing, creating a second line of defense.
  • Cricket or saddle. A peaked diverter behind the chimney (on the upslope side) that prevents water and debris from pooling. Not every chimney has one — but most should.

When any one of these components fails, water finds its way in. And water is patient — it doesn't need a big opening.

Why Chimney Flashing Fails in San Antonio

We see chimney flashing failures year-round, but certain conditions unique to our region accelerate the process:

  • Thermal cycling. San Antonio summers push roof surface temperatures above 150°F during the day, then drop 50+ degrees at night. Metal expands and contracts. Sealants crack. Nails back out. Over hundreds of cycles per year, even good flashing loosens.
  • Hail impact. A hailstorm doesn't just damage shingles — it dents and displaces flashing. We frequently find flashing that's been knocked out of alignment during hail damage repair inspections, even when the homeowner only reported shingle damage.
  • Improper original installation. This is the most common cause we see. Builders cutting corners with roofing cement instead of proper step flashing, or using single-piece flashing where a multi-part system is needed. It might last a few years, but it always fails eventually.
  • Mortar deterioration. The chimney's mortar joints break down over time, especially in our alkaline soil and humidity swings. When mortar crumbles, counter flashing loses its anchor and pulls free.
  • Missing cricket. If your chimney is wider than 30 inches and sits on the downslope side of a roof, building code requires a cricket. Many older San Antonio homes — particularly in neighborhoods like Alamo Heights and central San Antonio — were built without one. Water and leaves pool behind the chimney, accelerating rot and flashing failure.

How to Spot Chimney Flashing Problems

You don't need to climb on your roof to catch most warning signs. Here's what to watch for from the ground, inside, and (if you're comfortable) from a ladder:

Signs You Can See from Inside

  • Water stains on the ceiling or walls near the chimney. This is the most obvious sign, but by the time you see staining, water has often been getting in for weeks or months.
  • Musty smell in the attic near the chimney chase. Moisture trapped behind walls breeds mold fast in our humidity.
  • Damp or discolored drywall around the fireplace. Check the wall directly above and beside the firebox — this is where chimney leaks often show up first.
  • Peeling paint or bubbling wallpaper. Moisture behind the surface pushes finishes away from the substrate.

Signs You Can See from the Ground or a Ladder

  • Visible gaps between flashing and chimney masonry. Use binoculars if needed. Any daylight between the metal and the brick means water is getting in.
  • Rust stains running down the chimney or roof. Galvanized steel flashing eventually corrodes, especially in areas where standing water collects.
  • Flashing that's been sealed over with caulk or tar. This is a red flag. It means someone already tried to patch a problem without fixing the underlying failure. Caulk and roofing cement are temporary — they crack and shrink within a few years in our climate.
  • Shingles lifting or curling near the chimney. This can indicate water has been getting underneath and compromising the deck.
  • Debris buildup behind the chimney. If leaves, twigs, and granules are piled up on the upslope side, water is damming there during rain events.

Can Chimney Flashing Be Repaired, or Does It Need Replacement?

It depends on the failure mode. Minor issues — a small section of counter flashing that's pulled out of a mortar joint, a single piece of step flashing that's shifted — can often be addressed with a targeted roof repair. A skilled roofer will re-seat the flashing, re-point the mortar, and ensure proper overlap without relying on sealant alone.

But if the flashing is rusted through, if multiple components have failed, or if the underlying deck is rotted, you're looking at a full flashing replacement — and possibly some deck repair. If your roof is also near end of life, it often makes more sense to address the flashing during a full roof replacement rather than paying for standalone work twice.

What About Insurance?

If the flashing failure was caused by a covered peril — hail, wind, fallen debris — your homeowner's policy may cover the repair or replacement. Carriers like USAA, State Farm, and Amica all write policies in Bexar County that include roof damage from storms. We handle insurance claims regularly and can document the damage in a way adjusters understand. Wear-and-tear failures, on the other hand, are almost never covered.

Don't Ignore a Small Leak

Chimney flashing leaks rarely fix themselves, and they always get worse. A small drip during heavy rain turns into saturated decking, mold behind walls, and eventually a repair bill that's five or ten times what the original fix would have cost. We've pulled back flashing on homes in Stone Oak and Boerne and found rotted plywood that extended two or three feet from the chimney — all from a gap the homeowner thought was "too small to matter."

Not Sure About Your Chimney Flashing?

We'll check it for free. Our free roof inspection includes a close-up evaluation of all flashing, penetrations, and vulnerable transition points — not just a quick glance from the ground. If everything looks good, we'll tell you. If something needs attention, you'll get honest options and a written estimate. No pressure, no upsell.

Chimney flashing isn't glamorous, and it's easy to overlook. But it's one of the most critical waterproofing details on your roof. Catch problems early, hire someone who installs flashing correctly (not just caulks over the problem), and you'll avoid the kind of damage that turns a $300 repair into a $5,000 headache.

Ready for a straight answer on your roof?

Free, no-pressure inspection with photo-documented findings. Most inspections done within 48 hours.